Hayden Island resident Sam Churchill disputes the assertions made by IBR program Administrator Greg Johnson
Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in this letter to the editor are those of the author alone and do not reflect the editorial position of ClarkCountyToday.com
Mr. Greg Johnson, the Interstate Bridge Replacement program administrator, made a two-part video with “Ten reasons why a tunnel wouldn’t work at this location.”
The video is helpful. I appreciate the effort. But I’m not convinced:
(1) The Vancouver BC tunnel, now planned for under the Fraser River, has similar characteristics to our location, but is more cost/effective then their original bridge proposal. It costs $4.1B total — and NO toll! Their tunnel is NOT DOUBLE the cost. It’s HALF the cost of our proposed Columbia River bridge.
(2) Cars enter/leave the tunnel on their island (for potential direct island access).
(3) It does NOT require raising up an entire 5 mile length of freeway AND building steep access ramps to the raised freeway — in EXTREMELY earthquake prone sandy soil. That saves $2.5 Billion right there.
(4) Mr. Johnson needs a shallow grade for the Max train. What if there were NO Max trains? Instead, shuttles move people. Electric van pooling. No Max to Vancouver, WA. That saves another $2 billion.
(5) Since the IBR plans a new main river channel, the immersed tube could be close to the surface near the Vancouver shore. It would surface BEFORE the East/West railroad line. NO height restrictions!
Mr. Johnson makes a good point on personal safety. I think it can be addressed with free electric shuttle vehicles on the active transportation areas.
This tall bridge and corresponding raised freeway is ugly. It hurts economic development on both sides of the river. It reminds me of Seattle’s Alaskan Way, which has now been permanently torn down, stimulating NEW waterfront attractions.
Let’s lower the cost. Enhance livability. The IBR plan IS a disaster. We’ll ALL pay for it.
Sam Churchill
Hayden Island resident
Also read:
- Council member Belkot: Will pursue legal counsel if she is not reinstated to C-TRAN board
Clark County Council faces public outcry over Michelle Belkot’s removal from the C-TRAN board, with calls for reinstatement and legal action. - Opinion: ‘Michelle Belkot wants to protect your wallet and NOT pay for TriMet’s light rail O&M’Rep. John Ley urges area residents to show up to tonight’s Clark County Council meeting to support Belkot’s efforts
- C-TRAN Board shakeup: Belkot removed for standing against light rail boondoggleMichelle Belkot was removed from the C-TRAN Board after opposing light rail expansion, with Leslie Lewallen calling it political retaliation.
- Letter: IBR’s billion dollar risk, another Abernethy Bridge financial disaster?Bob Ortblad raises concerns over the IBR project’s feasibility, comparing its costs to the Abernethy Bridge overruns and pointing to a hidden geotechnical risk.
- Expect delays on I-5 North Fork Lewis River Bridge for annual inspections near Woodland, March 17-20
Drivers on I-5 near Woodland should expect delays as WSDOT conducts annual inspections on the North Fork Lewis River Bridge from March 17-20.
There are quite a few immersed multi lane tunnels in the Netherlands and other European countries for cars and trains and they work way better than bridges because of ship traffic.