‘We wanted to criticize authoritarian governments, but had no idea our own college would stop us’
Bob Unruh
WND News Center
An organization that started out protecting individual rights in America’s academic world, and now has expanded to call itself the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, still is working on college misbehavior.
The organization has announced a victory in its fight with a California college.
There, Clovis Community College had imposed an unconstitutional speech code “that resulted in the suppression of conservative students’ viewpoints.”
And that was struck down by a federal judge, the FIRE reported.
A judge ruled for three students from a chapter of Young Americans for Freedom who wanted to criticize authoritarianism on campus.
They did this by putting up posters listing the death tolls from communist regimes, which the school ordered taken down.
Judge Jennifer Thurston said, however, that the First Amendment doesn’t allow administrators to regulate the content of student speech by claiming that once students post a flyer, it suddenly “becomes” the college’s speech.
The court warned “a government entity cannot avoid constitutional requirements merely by declaring it can do so.”
“The court told Clovis what we’ve been telling them all along: You can’t censor students just because you don’t like their message,” said FIRE attorney Jeff Zeman. “The fight isn’t over. We’ve defeated this unconstitutional policy, but we won’t stop until Clovis treats all student speech equally.”
The court order instructed the college to drop its speech code.
“We wanted to criticize authoritarian governments, but we had no idea that our own college would try to stop us,” said YAF-Clovis founder Alejandro Flores. “I’m glad we fought back, because all students should be able to speak out at college.”
The fight came out of plans by Flores and club members Daniel Florses and Juliette Colunga. They got permission to hang three flyers on bulletin boards, citing those death tolls.
Explained the FIRE: “Emails obtained via a public records request reveal that soon after the flyers went up, a Clovis administrator wrote that he would ‘gladly’ take the flyers down, following complaints about their content. The administrator also wrote that approving the flyers in the first place may have been a ‘mistake,’ and that Clovis instead should have censored them under a policy that states: ‘Posters with inappropriate or offense [sic] language or themes are not permitted and will not be approved.'”
Lori Bennett, Clovis president, then ordered them removed, and invented “a brand new rule” that insists flyers double as club announcements.
“If you need a reason, you can let them know that [we] agreed they aren’t club announcements,” Bennett wrote to Clovis staff.
Only Clovis does not have a policy on the books that requires flyers to be club announcements, the FIRE said.
The school used the same pretext in banning pro-life flyers, too.
The organization said, “Public colleges like Clovis are bound by the First Amendment, and it is unconstitutional to treat student groups differently based on their viewpoints. Clovis’ vague policy banning ‘inappropriate’ or ‘offense [sic]’ themes — terms that could apply to just about anything — puts protected expression in jeopardy by allowing administrators to arbitrarily decide which opinions are inappropriate or offensive and which deserve to be heard.”
FIRE took to the courts last month, seeking to not just end the censorship but hold college officials accountable.
Also read:
- Fiscal fallout: $375 million bond debt indirectly funding operating budget
Shifting $375 million from a loan fund impacts local infrastructure as Washington state covers operating costs with bond debt, prompting concern among officials and advocacy groups. - Lawsuit aims to block new eligibility requirements for WA sheriffs
Four sheriffs are suing over a state law that sets new eligibility rules, arguing it undermines voter authority by allowing removal for certification issues. - Opinion: The growing gap between public voice and political power
Todd Myers describes how large-scale protest and sign-ins often fail to sway state leaders, and argues authentic influence is most likely found through local action. - City of Battle Ground seeks applicants for Salary Commission vacancy
Battle Ground seeks a resident to join its independent Salary Commission, which reviews compensation and health benefits for local elected officials through 2027. - Opinion: Who is winning the race for affordable power?
Hydroelectric power keeps Washington competitive, but new laws and carbon pricing are driving up electricity costs for residents each year. - Vancouver Fire Department assists with Columbia River Marina fire response
Vancouver Fire Department joined Clark-Cowlitz and Scappoose crews to help fight a vessel and dock fire at Goble Marina, assisting in river operations where one boat sank and another was partially submerged. - White House govt. Funding request for 2027 cuts $73 billion
President Trump’s budget seeks to boost defense funding while cutting $73 billion from agencies like the EPA, NASA, and Agriculture, prompting sharp criticism from Democratic leaders.
