Todd Myers says that just two and a half years into the CO2 tax, the policy has become another tax rather than a meaningful or effective climate policy

Todd Myers
Washington Policy Center

The Washington State Department of Ecology released the latest CO2 allowance results that set the price of the state’s carbon tax — the price jumped 16 percent in just one quarter. This is equivalent to about an 85 percent inflation rate over a year.

The price jumped from $50 per metric ton in the first quarter auction to $58.51 in the most recent quarter.

That price equates to about 46 cents per gallon for gasoline and 56 cents per gallon for diesel. To be clear, that is not on top of previous increases but is the new level for the state’s CO2 tax. It is an increase of about 6 cents per gallon from three months ago.

The CO2 tax will also increase the cost of natural gas home heating and other energy sources that emit CO2.

The big increase is not unexpected. The state’s CO2 tax is designed to increase steadily by continually restricting the number of allowances available for auction. As the supply of CO2 allowances declines, the price will continue to increase. These reductions will become more extreme. To meet Washington’s 2030 CO2 emissions goal will require reductions equivalent to three times the amount that occurred in 2020 during COVID.

Last year, activist groups that profit from the CO2 tax revenue, like the Clean and Prosperous Institute, claimed that the $29.88 per metric ton prices we saw last September were more typical of what we would see in the future. That claim was badly inaccurate. Prices have nearly doubled since then.

What do Washington state residents get for all this tax revenue? Not much environmental benefit. We don’t have good data on whether the CO2 tax is reducing emissions because the Department of Ecology is refusing to release updated emissions data, in violation of state law – as they themselves admitted in court recently.

The data we do have show that the vast majority of the spending does nothing to reduce emissions. The Department of Ecology’s own report on climate spending indicates that most of the projects they fund have, in their words, no “quantifiable emissions reductions.”

Just two and a half years into the CO2 tax, the policy has become another tax rather than a meaningful or effective climate policy. The prices will continue to climb even as state spending continues to fail to produce meaningful environmental benefits.        

Todd Myers is vice president for research at the Washington Policy Center.

---

Also read:

• 
  Letter: ‘One year later, a withheld text message points to perjury’
  Clark County resident Rob Anderson argues a previously undisclosed text message tied to a C-TRAN board dispute raises questions about sworn statements and public meeting rules.
• 
  Opinion: It’s not just the increased taxes that are driving businesses away
  Mark Harmsworth of the Washington Policy Center argues taxes, workforce challenges and economic uncertainty are driving businesses to relocate outside Washington.
• 
  Opinion: There is no such thing as a ‘free’ lunch, and an income tax isn’t more palatable because it offers one
  Elizabeth New of the Washington Policy Center argues the proposed Washington income tax and universal school meals policy reflect a broader state spending problem
• 
  Opinion: Democrat Party penalizes marriage in Washington
  Lars Larson argues that Washington’s newly passed income tax unfairly targets married couples by creating what he describes as a financial penalty for filing jointly.
• 
  Opinion: Gov. Ferguson has abandoned his own tax relief demands
  Ryan Frost of the Washington Policy Center argues that Gov. Bob Ferguson’s support for the state’s proposed income tax contradicts his earlier demands for broader taxpayer relief.