Vancouver resident Michael Backman challenges claim by C-TRAN board member, calling it ‘an empty statistical trick’

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in this letter to the editor are those of the author alone and may not reflect the editorial position of ClarkCountyToday.com

Paul Valencia’s recent article regarding Vancouver leaders pushing for fixed-rail infrastructure highlights a lack of critical context surrounding Councilor Erik Paulsen’s rhetoric.

Michael Backman

​Paulsen’s claim that “There is no other city in the state of Washington with 300,000 people in it that does not have fixed-rail service” is an empty statistical trick. Seattle is the only city in the entire state that actually meets that population tier. By that logic, there is also no other city of 300,000 people that has a purple city hall or a space needle — because there are no other cities of that size.

​Furthermore, his claim that converting The Vine BRT lines to a tram system is as simple as “laying the rail” completely glosses over the immense, disruptive engineering realities of rail conversion, utility overhauls, and electrification.

​Allowing local politicians to use misleading demographic metrics and oversimplified engineering claims completely unchecked does a disservice to Clark County taxpayers, who would ultimately foot the bill for these massive projects. Future reporting must challenge these assertions with objective data.

​

Michael Backman

Vancouver

---

Also read:

• 
  Opinion: Were Republican voters just sleeping during the August primary election?
  CCRP Chairman Matt Bumala says 60% of primary no-shows in the 17th and 18th districts were Republicans.
• 
  Opinion: WA Cares’ launch showcased care WA Cares did not provide
  Gov. Ferguson showcased a caregiving arrangement at the WA Cares launch that the program had not paid for a single day of.
• 
  Auditor, auditor candidate address scrutiny over job title
  Greg Kimsey says roughly 40 county employees hold the deputy county auditor designation Kelly used in his campaign.
• 
  Opinion: Is Mitchell Kelly misleading voters with his ‘deputy auditor’ claim?
  Clark County HR records show no position called “Deputy County Auditor” has ever existed, Anderson argues.
• 
  Opinion: Democrats rig the ballot to save their income tax
  Churchill argues the ballot disclosure warning voters of education cuts describes revenue never collected and not yet allocated.