Liv Finne believes one of the main reasons polls show a loss of faith in so many of our public institutions is the decline in the quality of public education and the trend of parents pulling their children out of the system

Liv Finne
Washington Policy Center

Yesterday Senator Lisa Wellman (D-Mercer Island), chair of the Senate Education Committee, led majority Democrats on her committee in passing ESHB 2331.  The bill would give a statewide executive branch official, the Superintendent of Public Instruction, new authority to cut the funding of any school that he deems is not requiring Critical Race Theory (CRT), Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) or Queer Theory (QT) lessons in the classroom.

Details on the bill and its potential impact on funding cuts is provided in our Legislative Memo analysis.  The funding-reduction authority is presented in Section 1, Subsection 2 of the bill.

Republicans on the Committee sought to protect school children from exposure to hurtful ideologies in the classroom.  Senator Jim McCune (R-Graham) proposed Amendment A, to prohibit school districts from approving instruction materials that are “lewd, obscene or pornographic.”  The amendment sought to keep school materials age-appropriate for children, more like “G” or “PG” rather than, “R” and “NC-17.”

Senator McCune described some of harmful classroom materials that would be required under ESHB 2331, as reported on TVW at Time Stamp 1:43:29 (https://tvw.org/video/senate-early-learning-k-12-education-2024021313/?eventID=2024021313.) 

Senator Wellman recommended a “No” vote and Amendment A was defeated.  The committee majority then voted to pass the underlying bill and send it to the full Senate for passage.

Senator Wellman said the bill would not undermine a local school district’s control over its own classroom materials.  This statement is not true.  The bill would cancel local control over instructional materials and give veto power to the state superintendent.  Anyone in doubt is invited to read the text of the bill (see ESHB 2331, Section 1, Subsection 2).

One of the main reasons polls show a loss of faith in so many of our public institutions is the decline in the quality of public education and the trend of parents pulling their children out of the system (Washington public schools have lost 46,000 families over the last few years).

Another reason is the increasingly common experience of hearing a public official say her proposed bill would do one thing, only to find on reading the bill that it would actually do the opposite.

Liv Finne is the director of the Center for Education at the Washington Policy Center.

---

Also read:

• 
  Opinion: Gov. Ferguson has abandoned his own tax relief demands
  Ryan Frost of the Washington Policy Center argues that Gov. Bob Ferguson’s support for the state’s proposed income tax contradicts his earlier demands for broader taxpayer relief.
• 
  Opinion: Many important decisions looming as the 2026 session nears the end
  Rep. John Ley outlines budget concerns, energy policy debates and several tax proposals as the 2026 legislative session approaches its final days.
• 
  Opinion: 106 striking workers already using unemployment insurance benefits
  A Washington Policy Center analyst says the state’s new law allowing striking workers to collect unemployment benefits is already affecting the UI system.
• 
  POLL: Who should have the primary say in decisions about a student’s gender identity at school?
  Clark County Today is asking readers who should have the primary role in decisions about a student’s gender identity at school.
• 
  Opinion: Study shows 2025’s record tax increases reduce Washington’s GDP growth and worker pay
  Todd Myers writes that a new economic analysis projects Washington’s 2025 tax increases will slow GDP growth and reduce wages over the next several years.