Ruling impacts buying or selling of high-capacity magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition
Brett Davis
The Center Square Washington
State Supreme Court Commissioner Michael Johnston ruled Thursday morning that the buying or selling of high-capacity magazines – those capable of holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition – will remain illegal in Washington while legal challenges against the ban are being decided.
That means Johnston is keeping in place an emergency stay he issued earlier this month.
The ban had been effectively overturned on April 8 when Cowlitz County Superior Court Judge Gary Bashor ruled the law itself was unconstitutional in a lawsuit between the state and Gator’s Custom Guns in Kelso and issued an injunction to stop the state from enforcing the ban.
Within 90 minutes of Bashor’s ruling, Johnston approved a request by the Attorney General’s Office to stay the lower court’s ruling.
Bashor in his ruling striking down Washington’s high-capacity magazine ban referenced the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision, in which the nation’s highest court ruled 6-3 that firearm regulations must be “consistent with the Nation’s historical tradition and firearm regulation.”
In Thursday’s 81-page opinion, Johnston circled back to “highly debatable” issues in Bashor’s decision that he mentioned in a hearing last week.
“Stated another way, debatability does not turn on a finding that the lower court erred, but rather, whether reasonable minds can differ on the issue at hand,” Johnston wrote, saying he considered the potential harm that could result from lifting the stay and allowing high-capacity magazines to be sold in the meantime.
“The historical record shows that [large-capacity magazines] greatly increase the number of fatalities and injuries inflicted in a mass shooting and that the frequency of such incidents has grown in recent years,” Johnston wrote. “The idea that I could lift the stay and something awful happens with a [large capacity magazine] that would not have been obtained but for that decision keeps me awake at night.”
Washington’s high-capacity magazine ban went into effect on July 1, 2022. The ban prohibits the sale of magazines with a capacity of more than 10 rounds, along with the manufacturing, distribution or import of said magazines in the state.
This report was first published by The Center Square Washington.
Also read:
- WA Senate Republicans unable to stop income tax bill now headed to governor’s desk
Washington lawmakers narrowly approved a new income tax on households earning over $1 million, setting the stage for court battles and a statewide initiative campaign. - 17th District lawmakers Kevin Waters and David Stuebe decry passage of state income tax bill after marathon floor debate
Reps. Kevin Waters and David Stuebe condemn Senate Bill 6346, warning the new state income tax sends more money into the general fund without real reform, risks expanding to every family, and ignores Washington’s affordability crisis. - Opinion: Washington’s fight for liberty
Conservative columnist Nancy Churchill argues that despite the passage of a new 9.9% state income tax, signs of shifting political momentum in Washington state give reason for hope and continued action. - 18th District Reps. Stephanie McClintock and John Ley denounce passage of state income tax
Following a marathon 24-hour House floor debate, 18th District Reps. Stephanie McClintock and John Ley denounce Senate Bill 6346, a new 9.9% state income tax on household income above $1 million, warning it could expand broadly, harm Washington’s economy, and face serious constitutional challenges. - County pays $7.5 million to widow of VPD Officer Donald Sahota
Clark County has agreed to pay $7.5 million to the widow of Vancouver Police Officer Donald Sahota to resolve a negligence lawsuit following the 2022 incident where a sheriff’s deputy mistakenly shot the off-duty officer during a confrontation with a robbery suspect. - Opinion: Brandi Kruse and I are feeling discouraged but we’re planning to continue advocating for political change. Will you?
Clark County Today Editor Ken Vance reflects on a discouraging week in Washington state politics, echoing Brandi Kruse’s frustrations over Democrats’ state income tax victory and local decisions on transit and ICE while urging conservatives not to give up on advocating for political change. - OII passes 60-day point in Vancouver Police Department use of deadly force investigation
The Washington State Office of Independent Investigations is just past 60 days into its investigation of a Vancouver Police Department use of deadly force involving officers Sean Donaldson and Christopher Holmquist and the death of 44-year-old Perry J. Sellars after a late-night disturbance call on NE 46th Street.
wpDiscuz
