David Boze of the Washington Policy Center shares an editorial from the Wall Street Journal that provides a ‘scathing analysis’ of Washington’s income tax on capital gains

David Boze
Washington Policy Center

The Wall Street Journal’s editorial board published a scathing analysis of Washington state’s income tax on capital gains (which, through some linguistic ideological twisting, our State Supreme Court opted to call our “excise tax on capital gains”). 

They allude to the fact the tax is tied to income but masquerades as a transactional tax because a progressive tax on income would violate the Washington State Constitution, then dig into where the hubris of its creators created a problem for themselves — they tax “transactions” out of state in violation of the Commerce Clause.  

The Journal makes short work of the tax’s defenders argument that it is the same as an internet tax and concludes with a warning about the tax both constitutional and practical while quoting WPC’s amicus brief:

This should be enough to sink the tax at the Supreme Court, but also don’t overlook its practical problems. Allowing interstate excise taxes “threatens to wreak havoc on taxpayers and businesses around the country,” as the Washington Policy Center put it in an amicus brief filed Monday. Washington residents already have a headache in figuring out which sales trigger the tax.

Read the full Wall Street Journal editorial here (warning: WSJ has a paywall). If you hit the paywall problem, MSN has reprinted it here. 

David Boze is the communications director at the Washington Policy Center.

---

Also read:

• 
  Opinion: Parents told to have a seat; government knows best
  Elizabeth New says recent Washington legislation chips away at parental rights by allowing schools to facilitate health services without parent notification.
• 
  POLL: Should schools notify parents about a student’s gender identity?
  Clark County Today’s weekly poll asks whether schools should notify parents if a student questions their gender identity, as debate intensifies over La Center School District’s policy and a new federal investigation.
• 
  Op-Ed: La Center Schools — Committed to families and their children
  In a public letter, the La Center School Board and Superintendent Peter Rosenkranz affirm their commitment to supporting families and honoring both state law and community values amid state-level scrutiny.
• 
  Letter: ‘You don’t fix a struggling system by starving it’
  Rye Dilley, a student at Tukes Valley Middle School, urges Battle Ground voters to support the school levy to avoid deep cuts in essential programs and services.
• 
  Letter: ‘What is this Country becoming?’
  Steven Zimmerman of Brush Prairie questions the direction of the country, raising concerns about presidential overreach and the erosion of civil liberties.