
Property is government-owned and it must ‘comply with the Constitution’
Bob Unruh
WND News Center
A panel of judges on the Tennessee Appeals Court has ruled that an apartment lease provision banning the tenant from having a firearm is unconstitutional and unenforceable.
The decision in the case involving Columbia resident Kinsley Braden and the Columbia Housing & Redevelopment Corp. was documented by the Second Amendment Foundation.
The three-judge panel, in an opinion written by Judge Frank. G. Clement Jr., said, “(I)n light of the Supreme Court’s most recent decision in Bruen and keeping in mind the presumptively unconstitutional status of Columbia Housing’s policy based on the Supreme Court’s decision in Heller, we conclude that a total ban on the ability of law-abiding residents—like Mr. Braden—to possess a handgun within their public housing unit for the purpose of self-defense is unconstitutional under the Second Amendment.”
The noted that the housing organization, in fact, “is a government entity acting as a landlord of property it owns.”
Because it is a government operation, the housing organization must abide by the Constitution, and if it wants a firearm ban, must “establish that its leasehold restrictions on firearms is ‘consistent with the Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.'”
The case was sent back to a lower court for further proceedings.
Clement was joined by Judges Andy D. Bennett and W. Neal McBrayer in the unanimous ruling.
“We’re delighted with the appeals court ruling,” said SAF founder Alan M. Gottlieb. “This underscores the far-reaching effect of the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark Bruen opinion. Mr. Braden was evicted from the public housing complex because he had a firearm. The court properly held that such a prohibition is a non-starter. Rulings like this make it clear the Second Amendment means what it says.”
The court decision noted not only is the public housing “government-owned,” “the leased premises at issue is the tenant’s private home, which is not the kind of ‘sensitive place’ where the government may categorically ban firearm possession.”
Further, it noted, complete bans on handguns in homes for self-defense “are ‘historically unprecedented.'”
The lower court had found that Braden waived his rights to possess a firearm by agreeing to the lease.
However, that ruling didn’t take notice of the fact that the owner was, in fact, a government operation that is bound by the Second Amendment, a point upon which the appeals ruling was based.
“As a threshold matter, we recognize that Columbia Housing is a government entity acting as the landlord of the Creekside Acre residences. … For this reason, the actions of Columbia Housing and the policies of Creekside Acres must conform to the Constitution.”
Also read:
- Vancouver Police accepting applications for upcoming Neighbors On Watch AcademyThe Vancouver Police Department is seeking volunteers to join the mission of making Vancouver the safest urban city in Washington.
- Woodland Middle School’s Drama Department presents ‘Giants in the Sky,’ the school’s first in-person performance since 2020Drama students at Woodland Middle School will perform the school’s first play since 2020 in March, ‘Giants in the Sky,’ a musical performance exploring the world of Giants who live above the clouds
- Ridgefield Public Schools Foundation hosts fundraiser to send RHS Knowledge Bowl to National Quiz BowlThe Ridgefield Public Schools Foundation has kicked-off a week-long matching fundraiser to help get the Ridgefield High School Knowledge Bowl team to the National Quiz Bowl to be held in Atlanta in May.
- Rep. Paul Harris bill to reevaluate teacher reprimands unanimously passes off the House floorThe Washington State House of Representatives on Monday unanimously passed legislation from Rep. Paul Harris that would give educators with a reprimand an opportunity for redemption.
- One deceased and one seriously injured in vehicle fire in Hazel DellAn area resident reported they believed two people were living in the van that caught on fire.
- Red light, don’t turn right bill introduced to Washington LegislatureUnder legislation proposed in the Washington state Senate, drivers would face new limits on when it’s permissible to make a right turn at red lights.
- Stunner! Professional ‘journalists’ decide news has no place for objectivityThe legacy media in America are cutting their own throats, shooting themselves in the feet and calling for their own termination, according to an analysis by constitutional expert Jonathan Turley.