![During a court hearing Tuesday in the case of State of Washington v. John Ley, concerns were raised about the prosecution’s preparedness and the completeness of its investigation.](https://www.clarkcountytoday.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Large_Clark-County-Today-Concerns-expressed-by-judge-over-prosecutions-preparedness-and-investigation-highlight-hearing-in-John-Ley-case.jpg)
Judge John Fairgrieve expressed concerns about the completeness of the investigation, and noted the infrequency of such charges being brought and the challenges it presents
Ken Vance, editor
ClarkCountyToday.com
A public hearing was held Tuesday (Jan. 9) in the voter registration case in Clark County against former legislative candidate John Ley The hearing was to address four significant motions filed in the case by Attorney Angus Lee, who represents Ley.
![John Ley](https://www.clarkcountytoday.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Mug_Clark-County-Today-John-Ley.jpg)
The hearing, held in Clark County Superior Court, featured some compelling comments from Judge John Fairgrieve, who essentially admonished the prosecution for its lack of preparedness and investigation that led to the charges against Ley., a Republican candidate for Washington state’s 18th Legislative District state representative Position No. 2 in 2022. Ley is charged with allegedly registering to vote and as a candidate in an incorrect voter district.
Judge Fairgrieve, a former chief deputy prosecutor for Clark County, expressed concerns during the hearing about the completeness of the investigation, and noted the infrequency of such charges being brought and the challenges it presents. “These types of charges are very infrequent. First time I’ve actually seen these types of charges,” Fairgrieve stated. The judge acknowledged the unusual nature of the case and the unfamiliarity of law enforcement officers in investigating such matters, suggesting that this might have contributed to the oversight in the collection of evidence.
![Attorney Angus Lee](https://www.clarkcountytoday.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Mug_Clark-County-Today-Angus-Lee.jpg)
According to Lee, Fairgrieve was referring to the fact that the state law used to charge Ley has only led to three convictions in the state of Washington in more than 100 years and two of those cases were more than 100 years ago. In addition to that, in each of the three cases, the convicted parties later had those convictions reversed on appeal.
Judge Fairgrieve further pointed out the importance of the defense’s motion for specific documents – the specific voter registration application and declaration of candidacy at issue in the charges against Ley. “It seems to me that this is not an unreasonable request on the part of the defense,” Fairgrieve remarked, emphasizing the legitimacy of the defense’s pursuit of these documents.
Highlighting a potential gap in the prosecution’s case preparation, Judge Fairgrieve expressed surprise that the critical documents were not collected during the initial investigation. “I’m a little surprised that they were not collected during the initial investigation of this case,” he observed, raising questions about the thoroughness of the prosecution’s approach.
The judge also addressed the state’s uncertainty regarding the form and availability of the requested documents. “So at this point, it seems to me that the state’s saying, well, we’re not quite sure what form these documents might be in, and you don’t have ’em at this point, is that right?”
Deputy Prosecutor Erik Podhora responded to Fairgrieve by confirming that the prosecution did not have possession of the declarations that Ley was accused of falsely submitting. The motion for the prosecution to compel those documents will be heard at a hearing on Feb. 15.
“We filed all four motions appropriately, meeting minimum time requirements under the rule, and the prosecution just wasn’t prepared to respond,’’ Lee told Clark County Today.
Another of Lee’s four motions filed challenged the legality of the search conducted by the Clark County Sheriff’s Office, targeting the contents of Ley’s text message communications. The motion highlighted three key areas of concern: the absence of a signed affidavit by the officer as required by the Constitution, the failure to disclose exculpatory information, and the overly broad scope of the warrant. The prosecution wasn’t prepared to argue that motion so Fairgrieve scheduled it for a March 15 hearing so they could have more time.
The same was the case with Lee’s motion to dismiss, which will also be heard on March 15 The motion for dismissal cited a lack of evidence, based on statements from the primary investigating officer, who expressed belief in Ley’s truthfulness. The officer’s probable cause statement in this case says “[a]s a result of my investigation and analysis, I do not believe John Ley intentionally lied.”
Another motion filed by the defense was that the charging document provided by the prosecution was not sufficient. Instead of arguing the motion, the prosecution provided a new charging document. The hearing on Feb. 15 will determine if the new charging document is sufficient.
Defense Attorney Angus Lee later stated that “the charges should not have been filed until a full and thorough investigation was completed.” He added, “the government can’t claim it is defending democracy when prosecuting a candidate before the investigation is even complete.” Lee further noted that the government is accusing Candidate Ley of misfiling in 2022, adding, “There is no excuse for charging a case that has not been fully investigated over a year and a half later.”
Clark County Today will continue to report on this case.
Also read:
- Opinion: OIC tells consumers not to pay for ‘insurance’ you won’t likely benefit from: Does that include WA Cares?Elizabeth New (Hovde) of the Washington Policy Center believes you should consider yourself warned by the Office of the Insurance Commissioner about WA Cares and its maybe-only benefit.
- Opinion: Same road, different speed limit?Target Zero Manager Doug Dahl addresses a question about speed limit signs going into and leaving town.
- Progress being made at GRO Parade of Homes siteThe 2024 GRO Parade of Homes, presented by the Building Industry Association of Clark County, is a little more than a month away, and builders are busy completing the luxury homes before the big event, scheduled for Sept. 6 through 22 in Felida.
- Has trust in the media tanked over coverage of President Biden’s decline?After President Joe Biden’s calamitous debate performance against former President Donald Trump, and days after Biden’s decision Sunday not to seek reelection, there are still many questions about how the news media covered Biden’s mental and physical decline.
- Opinion: Hiding the growing cost of the Interstate Bridge replacementJoe Cortright of the City Observatory addresses the rising cost of the Interstate 5 Bridge replacement project.
- Letter: ‘This election I am NOT voting for Greg Cheney’Clark County resident Wynn Grcich shares her thoughts on Rep. Greg Cheney and the issue of fluoridation in area drinking water.
- Major gas line leak closes major arterial in Clark CountyFirefighters from Clark County Fire District 6 responded Thursday (July 25) afternoon to the scene of a major natural gas leak on NE 99th Street, directly in front of Columbia River High School.