Chris Cargill of the Mountain States Policy Center says Washington lawmakers need to take a look in the mirror
Chris Cargill
Mountain States Policy Center
State legislators in Washington state have a big budget challenge ahead of them. If they want to know why, they should look in the mirror.
When the Evergreen State’s legislative session opens next month, lawmakers will be staring at a massive budget shortfall – a whopping $10-12 billion. And let’s be clear – the gap has nothing whatsoever to do with tax revenue. In fact, tax revenue is growing dramatically.
Instead, the issue is the colossal failure by lawmakers to control spending or prioritize tax relief. The budget chasm Washington finds itself facing is not occurring in neighboring states. For example, the current headlines in Montana and Wyoming are about major tax relief proposals while Idaho lawmakers are discussing even more tax cuts building on the reductions already enacted.
This different fiscal outlook between the states can directly be traced to the contrasting governing philosophies. While policymakers in Idaho, Montana and Wyoming prioritized tax relief and fiscally conservative budgeting over the last several years, Washington lawmakers have been doing their best Thelma and Louise impersonation by stepping on the spending gas. In doing so, they are driving the state over the fiscal cliff.
Consider the fact that even though revenue was growing significantly, Washington lawmakers not only failed to provide any broad-based tax relief but instead accelerated their spending even faster aided by tax increases, including imposing a new capital gains income tax.
Based on the response from legislative leadership, it sounds like Washington policymakers plan to double down on this tax and spend philosophy by imposing even more tax increases in 2025. Consider this report from KING 5 News: “Tax increases, and potentially new tax proposals, will be on the table when Washington state legislators convene in Olympia in January for an historic session.”
Washington’s massive spending increases and lack of tax relief aren’t just a contrast with more fiscally conservative states. Oregon taxpayers are scheduled to receive nearly $1 billion in tax relief and New York’s Democratic Governor is proposing $500 “Inflation Refund” checks for next year. Governor Hochul said, “It’s simple: the cost of living is still too damn high, and New Yorkers deserve a break.” I’m sure that Washingtonians would agree with that sentiment of their taxes being “too damn high” as well.
It is time for Washington policymakers to follow the budget Hippocratic Oath and do no more harm by getting spending under control. One place to start is to learn from the example of former Gov. Christine Gregoire.
Facing a significant budget shortfall in 2008, Gregoire wisely concluded that the pay raises she had agreed to for state employees weren’t “financially feasible.” Realizing that current and outgoing Governor Jay Inslee has already ordered a freeze on hiring, services contracts, goods and equipment purchases, and travel, it’s safe to assume the billions in pay raises he secretly agreed to this summer are also not “financially feasible” either. Right?
Do Washington lawmakers really plan to impose tax increases to provide government pay raises?
Chris Cargill is the president of Mountain States Policy Center, an independent research organization based in Idaho, Montana, Wyoming and Eastern Washington. Online at mountainstatespolicy.org.
Also read:
- Opinion: Transit agencies need accountability not increased state subsidy
Charles Prestrud argues that Washington transit agencies face rising costs and declining ridership due to governance structures that lack public accountability. - Letter: ‘For years, American foreign policy too often felt like a blank check’
Vancouver resident Peter Bracchi argues that the 2025 National Security Strategy marks a long-overdue shift toward clearer priorities, shared responsibility, and interest-based American leadership. - POLL: Are you better off than you were a year ago?
This week’s poll asks readers to reflect on their personal financial situation and whether they feel better off than they were a year ago as economic conditions continue to shift. - Opinion: Does tailgating cause speeding?
Target Zero Manager Doug Dahl examines whether tailgating contributes to speeding and explains why following too closely increases crash risk with little benefit. - Opinion: ‘The Democrats’ part of the bargain’
Clark County Today Editor Ken Vance reflects on a New Year’s Eve encounter and a Bill Maher commentary to assess what he sees as cultural and political changes from the past year.
