Letter: ‘If we want workable immigration reform, we must first restore basic human dignity to the debate’



Vancouver resident John Ford says leaders and media outlets must stop laundering dehumanizing metaphors as “tough talk’’

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in this letter to the editor are those of the author alone and may not reflect the editorial position of ClarkCountyToday.com

America’s immigration system is in crisis, but a second crisis is unfolding in public: “digital deportation squads.” As Maria Garcia (2023) reports, social media users post videos of people they assume are undocumented — often alongside ICE hotline numbers — urging followers to “report them.” This is not random trolling; it is the downstream effect of decades of dehumanizing narratives that portray migrants as a “flood” or an “invasion” (Santa Ana, 2002), making intimidation feel like civic duty.

John Ford
John Ford

Platforms then accelerate the harm. Engagement-driven algorithms reward fear and outrage, pushing sensational confrontation clips over nuanced policy analysis (Fisher & Taub, 2019) and stitching angry viewers into echo chambers where harassment is socially rewarded. The result is real-world damage: families fear public spaces, false reports waste resources, and the policy conversation collapses into racialized spectacle.

Deleting posts is insufficient. Leaders and media outlets must stop laundering dehumanizing metaphors as “tough talk,” and journalists should treat “invasion” rhetoric as a public-safety risk, not a headline hook. If we want workable immigration reform, we must first restore basic human dignity to the debate.

John Ford
Vancouver


Also read:

3 Comments

  1. Paula Person

    John Ford’s perception and comments are well worth reviewing and discussing. Social media may be interesting but it also slanted, biased, and dangerous.
    ICE is becoming more dangerous everyday and affecting many legal citizens.

    Reply
    1. Bob Koski

      Per wiki: A citizen is a legally recognized member of a sovereign state (like a country), holding specific rights (like voting, working, residing) and duties (like paying taxes, obeying laws) within that political community, often acquired by birth in the territory (jus soli) or by descent (jus sanguinis), or through a legal process called naturalization, forming a bond of allegiance and identity.

      That means legally defined actual citizens have absolutely nothing to fear from Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents, but non-citizens who are in this country illegally certainly do. Fear mongering, pearl clutching and mass hysteria accomplish nothing on immigration and many other current subjects as well.

      Remain calm and carry on.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *