The lawsuit argues that HB 1240 violates the Second Amendment
TJ Martinell
The Center Square Washington
A federal judge has denied a request by a coalition of gun rights advocates for a preliminary injunction against a recently enacted Washington state law banning the purchase or sale of firearms deemed “assault weapons.”
The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. Western Washington District Court by the Firearms Policy Coalition and Second Amendment Foundation, arguing that HB 1240 violates the Second Amendment. Two other lawsuits have been filed against the law, one at the federal level and another at the state level.
The lawsuit argues that the “assault weapon” ban violates two recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions, Heller and Bruen, regarding the right to keep and bear arms.
However, the federal judge argued in his denial for the preliminary injunction that the plaintiffs “misread” those decisions.
The judge further wrote that the lawsuit is “marked by argument without citations and sources showing that their argument would be supported by admissible evidence, even under the relaxed rules for preliminary injunctions. It is wholly unclear whether all of the weapons (like conversion kits or semiautomatic pistols) regulated by HB 1240 are “in common use” based on the Plaintiffs’ scant submission.”
The judge also opined that “HB 1240’s proponents have shown that unprecedented social concerns have arisen from the proliferation of these weapons. These weapons are exceptionally dangerous,” adding that the plaintiffs seeking to purchase firearms banned under HB 1240 “have other alternative weapons available, particularly for self-defense.”
He added “public opinion is apparently strongly divided between the Plaintiffs and Defendants – between those who wish unfettered access to assault weapons and those who seek to curtail that access for public protection. From the record here, neither position reflects the true public interest nor balances the equities in the favor of the Plaintiffs.
In a statement following the judge’s decision, State Attorney Bob Ferguson wrote that “we remain undefeated against the gun lobby in court. This common-sense gun reform will save lives by restricting access to the preferred weapon of mass shooters.”
This report was first published by The Center Square Washington.
Also read:
- High school girls basketball: Union Titans give Brooklynn Haywood a homecoming in Alaska
Union traveled to Anchorage for two games that allowed Brooklynn Haywood to play in front of her hometown crowd while the Titans bonded through travel, cold weather, and on-court adversity. - WATCH – Detransitioner to providers: ‘Please just stop’ gender surgeries on minors
Detransitioner Soren Aldaco shared her experience and urged providers to stop encouraging gender surgeries on minors as HHS moves to restrict federal funding for such procedures. - Without pennies, should retailers round up or down?
As the penny disappears from circulation, states and retailers are grappling with how cash purchases should be rounded and who should benefit from those decisions. - Opinion: IBR promotes ‘giving away’ historic interstate bridges while withholding cost estimate for replacement
Neighbors for a Better Crossing argues the IBR program is promoting demolition of the historic Interstate Bridges without releasing updated cost estimates or current seismic data to justify replacement. - Opinion: Solving Washington’s deficit without tax increases
Ryan Frost argues Washington’s budget shortfall is driven by rapid spending growth rather than insufficient tax revenue, calling for slower spending and program reductions instead of new taxes. - Washington State Patrol loses 34th trooper in the line of duty
Washington State Patrol Trooper Tara-Marysa Guting was killed while investigating a crash on State Route 509 in Tacoma, marking the 34th line-of-duty death in the agency’s history. - Opinion: Bikes in crosswalks
Doug Dahl explains how Washington law treats bicycles as both vehicles and pedestrians, depending on where and how they are being ridden.
