Liv Finne says why risk a child’s future on a teacher from a training program that’s getting an ‘F’ in reading instruction, when lawmakers in other states are actually helping parents educate their children
Liv Finne
Washington Policy Center
The National Council on Teacher Quality (NCTQ) just released a new report that evaluates 700 teacher training programs in states across the country. The report assesses the performance of state-level programs in training instructors on how to teach children to read.
Washington state’s programs did not fare well, ranking among the worst in the nation in providing qualified teachers for public schools.
Only one program received an “A”, and only a single program rated a “B”. Both were earned by WSU for its undergraduate and graduate teacher-training programs, respectively. Meanwhile, fully two-thirds of the programs, eight out of 12, ranked “F”, and the two remaining programs rated a “C”.
Here are the full NCTQ scores for Washington state.
Central Washington University, Undergraduate C
Centralia College, Undergraduate F
City University of Seattle, Undergraduate F
City University of Seattle, Graduate F
Eastern Washington University, Undergraduate C
Eastern Washington University, Graduate F
University of Washington—Bothell, Graduate F
University of Washington—Seattle, Graduate F
University of Washington — Tacoma, Graduate F
Washington State University, Undergraduate A
Washington State University, Graduate B
Western Washington University F
These failures do the most harm to vulnerable student groups. On the 2022 NAEP 4th grade reading test, only 16 percent of Hispanic students, 25 percent of Black students, six percent of English Language Learners and 16 percent students with disabilities read at proficiency levels.
State law requires that people wanting to teach in public schools complete one of these programs. Except for those attending WSU this mandate is clearly not working. The latest National Assessment of Education Progress (NAEP) scores show only 34% of Washington public school student can read proficiently.
At the same time the mandate does not apply to private schools, which are free to hire any qualified person as an instructor without restriction. Similarly, homeschooled students have access to any qualified instructors as arranged by their parents, including the parents themselves.
The poor quality of training at Washington’s formal Schools of Education is unlikely to change. Teacher training programs are an integral part of the public education monopoly, and protecting it is a top priority for powerful WEA union and their political allies. In fact, the hardliners are driving families to avoid public education altogether.
Already this year lawmakers in five states have enacted universal school choice, bringing the total to seven states that give parents direct access to funding to pay for alternatives like online or private school tuition.*
Four million public school students are now newly eligible for publicly-funded educational choice. The Arizona program provides $7,000 per child, and applications have exploded since the law passed in 2022. Iowa lawmakers passed a school choice law in January, and already 17,520 students have applied to receive up to $7,600 each.
Washington’s persistent poor teacher quality, low academic achievement and the advancements made by other states are powerful incentives for more families to pull out of the public system. After all, why risk a child’s future on a teacher from a training program that’s getting an “F” in reading instruction, when lawmakers in other states are actually helping parents educate their children.
* Arizona, West Virginia, Iowa, Utah, Arkansas, Florida and Oklahoma.
Liv Finne is the director of the Center for Education at the Washington Policy Center.
Also read:
- Opinion: As more states enact learning choice programs that benefit children, nearly one million families have applied to participate
Liv Finne of the Washington Policy Center reports that an exciting opportunity has emerged from the damage inflicted on students from the extended COVID public school shutdowns and school curriculum controversies. - Opinion: Can we actually stop some dangerous driving?
Doug Dahl, the Target Zero manager and communications lead, has a question for Washington drivers. - POLL: Do you agree with the decision of the jury that Vancouver Police Officer Andrea Mendoza was not guilty of assault?Do you agree with the decision of the jury that Vancouver Police Officer Andrea Mendoza was not guilty of assault?
- Opinion: Gov. Inslee’s latest wasteful EV subsidy is the equivalent of paying $1,125 for a latteTodd Myers of the Washington Policy Center says that we can expect Washington’s elected officials to continue to prioritize politics over the planet.
- Opinion: Not guilty verdict appropriate resolution in case of VPD officerClark County Today Editor Ken Vance offers his praise to the jury in the trial of Vancouver Police Officer Andrea Mendoza.
